Techniques

Killer Sudoku 45 Rule Explained: Complete Guide to Using This Powerful Technique

Thursday, April 10, 2025

Introduction

The 45 Rule is one of the most powerful and elegant techniques in Killer Sudoku. It's based on a simple mathematical truth: in any row, column, or 3×3 box, the digits 1 through 9 must sum to exactly 45. This fundamental principle opens up countless solving opportunities that can dramatically speed up your puzzle-solving process.

Understanding and mastering the 45 Rule is essential for anyone serious about Killer Sudoku. Whether you're solving easy puzzles or tackling expert-level challenges, this technique will become one of your most valuable tools. This comprehensive guide will teach you everything you need to know about the 45 Rule, from basic applications to advanced strategies.

What Is the 45 Rule in Killer Sudoku?

The 45 Rule is a mathematical principle that states: every row, column, and 3×3 box in a Sudoku grid must contain the digits 1 through 9 exactly once, and these digits always sum to 45 (1+2+3+4+5+6+7+8+9 = 45).

In Killer Sudoku, this rule becomes powerful because you can use cage sums to determine unknown values. If you know the sum of all cages within a row, column, or box, you can subtract that total from 45 to find the sum of any remaining uncaged cells.

Why It Works

The 45 Rule works because:

  • Each row must contain digits 1-9 (sum = 45)
  • Each column must contain digits 1-9 (sum = 45)
  • Each 3×3 box must contain digits 1-9 (sum = 45)
  • This is true regardless of the puzzle's difficulty or cage arrangement

Basic Application

The simplest application: if a row contains cages that sum to 40, and there's one cell not in any cage, that cell must be 5 (45 - 40 = 5).

Key Points

Essential concepts for using the 45 Rule effectively:

  • Mathematical foundation: The rule is based on the fixed sum of digits 1-9, which is always 45
  • Cage sum subtraction: Subtract the sum of known cages from 45 to find remaining cell values
  • Innies and outies: Single cells inside or outside a region can be determined using the 45 Rule
  • Multiple 45 Rule: Extend the technique to multiple rows or columns for advanced deductions
  • Combination with other techniques: The 45 Rule works best when combined with cage analysis and traditional Sudoku methods
  • Systematic approach: Always check rows, columns, and boxes for 45 Rule opportunities

How It Works (Step-by-Step)

Step 1: Identify the Region

First, choose a row, column, or 3×3 box to analyze. Look for regions where:

  • Most cells are part of cages with known sums
  • One or more cells are not in any cage (or are in incomplete cages)
  • The cage sums are easy to calculate

Step 2: Calculate Cage Sums

Add up all the cage sums within your chosen region. Be careful to:

  • Include only cages that are completely within the region
  • For cages that cross region boundaries, include only the cells within your region
  • Double-check your addition to avoid errors

Step 3: Apply the 45 Rule

Subtract the total cage sum from 45:

  • Remaining sum = 45 - (sum of cages in region)

This tells you what the uncaged cells (or incomplete cage cells) must sum to.

Step 4: Make Deductions

Use the remaining sum to:

  • Determine single cell values (if only one cell remains)
  • Narrow down possibilities for multiple cells
  • Eliminate impossible combinations
  • Create new solving opportunities

Step 5: Verify and Continue

Always verify your deductions follow Sudoku rules, then use the new information to make further progress in the puzzle.

Examples

Example 1: Single Cell (Innie)

Imagine a row where:

  • Cage 1 (3 cells) = 12
  • Cage 2 (4 cells) = 18
  • One cell is not in any cage

Calculation:

  • Total cage sum = 12 + 18 = 30
  • Remaining cell = 45 - 30 = 15

Wait—this is impossible! A single cell can't be 15. This means either:

  • Your cage sums are incorrect, or
  • The cell must be part of a cage you haven't identified

This is actually a useful check: if the math doesn't work, you've found an error or missed information.

Example 2: Single Cell (Correct Application)

A row contains:

  • Cage 1 (2 cells) = 8
  • Cage 2 (3 cells) = 15
  • Cage 3 (3 cells) = 19
  • One cell is not in any cage

Calculation:

  • Total cage sum = 8 + 15 + 19 = 42
  • Remaining cell = 45 - 42 = 3

Result: The uncaged cell must be 3. This is a valid deduction you can use immediately.

Example 3: Multiple Cells

A box contains:

  • Cage 1 (2 cells) = 7
  • Cage 2 (2 cells) = 13
  • Three cells are not in any cage

Calculation:

  • Total cage sum = 7 + 13 = 20
  • Remaining cells sum = 45 - 20 = 25

The three uncaged cells must sum to 25. Possible combinations:

  • 7, 9, 9 (invalid—can't repeat 9)
  • 8, 8, 9 (invalid—can't repeat 8)
  • 7, 8, 10 (invalid—10 doesn't exist)
  • 6, 9, 10 (invalid—10 doesn't exist)
  • 7, 8, 10 (invalid)
  • 6, 8, 11 (invalid)
  • 5, 9, 11 (invalid)
  • 4, 9, 12 (invalid)
  • 3, 9, 13 (invalid)
  • 2, 9, 14 (invalid)
  • 1, 9, 15 (invalid)

Actually, let's think differently. The three cells must contain three different digits that sum to 25. The maximum sum of three different digits (7, 8, 9) is 24. So three cells can't sum to 25—this means the box must have a cage you haven't accounted for, or your calculation needs adjustment.

Example 4: Outie (Cell Outside Region)

Sometimes a cell outside a region can be determined. For example:

  • A column has cages summing to 44
  • One cell in an adjacent column extends into this column's region
  • That "outie" cell = 45 - 44 = 1

This is particularly useful when analyzing boxes with cells that extend into neighboring regions.

Advanced Applications

Multiple 45 Rule

The Multiple 45 Rule applies the 45 Rule to multiple rows or columns simultaneously. For example:

  • Two adjacent columns together should sum to 90 (45 + 45)
  • If the cages in these columns sum to 92, the excess (2) must come from cells outside these columns that are counted in the calculation
  • This can reveal values for cells in neighboring regions

Combining with Cage Analysis

The 45 Rule becomes even more powerful when combined with cage combination analysis:

  1. Use the 45 Rule to find what cells must sum to
  2. Analyze which digit combinations can achieve that sum
  3. Eliminate combinations that violate Sudoku rules
  4. Narrow down to valid possibilities

Box Analysis

Boxes are particularly useful for the 45 Rule because:

  • They're smaller regions (9 cells)
  • Cage boundaries often align with box boundaries
  • Multiple cages within a box create many deduction opportunities

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Including partial cages: Only count cells that are completely within your region
  • Double-counting: Be careful not to count the same cell twice
  • Ignoring box boundaries: Remember that cages can cross box boundaries
  • Forgetting to verify: Always check that your deductions follow Sudoku rules
  • Overlooking innies/outies: Single cells are the easiest 45 Rule applications

Summary

The 45 Rule is a fundamental technique that every Killer Sudoku solver should master. It's based on simple mathematics but opens up powerful solving opportunities. By understanding how to subtract cage sums from 45, identify innies and outies, and apply the rule systematically, you can solve puzzles faster and tackle more challenging grids.

The key to success is practice: the more you use the 45 Rule, the more naturally you'll spot opportunities to apply it. Combine it with cage analysis and traditional Sudoku techniques, and you'll have a comprehensive solving toolkit that can handle even the most difficult Killer Sudoku puzzles.

Ready to practice? Try our Killer Sudoku puzzles and apply the 45 Rule to improve your solving speed!

❓ FAQ

Q1: Why is it called the 45 Rule?

The rule is named after the sum of digits 1 through 9, which equals 45. This sum is constant for every row, column, and box in a Sudoku grid.

Q2: Can the 45 Rule be used in regular Sudoku?

Yes, but it's less useful because regular Sudoku doesn't have cage sums. The 45 Rule in regular Sudoku mainly helps verify that a region contains all digits 1-9.

Q3: What's the difference between an innie and an outie?

An innie is a single cell inside a region (row/column/box) that's not part of any cage. An outie is a cell outside the region that extends into it. Both can be determined using the 45 Rule.

Q4: How do I know if I can use the 45 Rule?

Look for regions where most cells are in cages with known sums, and one or more cells are uncaged or in incomplete cages. If the math works out (cage sums + remaining cells = 45), you can make deductions.

Q5: Can the 45 Rule determine multiple cell values?

Yes, but it gives you the sum of those cells, not individual values. You'll need to combine it with other techniques (like cage combinations or Sudoku rules) to determine specific digits.

Q6: What if the 45 Rule calculation gives an impossible result?

If the math doesn't work (like a single cell equaling 15), it means either your cage sums are wrong, you've missed a cage, or there's an error in the puzzle setup. This is actually useful for error-checking.

Q7: Is the Multiple 45 Rule difficult to learn?

The Multiple 45 Rule is more advanced but follows the same principle. Start by mastering the basic 45 Rule on single regions, then practice applying it to multiple rows or columns.

Q8: How often should I use the 45 Rule?

Use it whenever you see an opportunity—it's one of the most frequently applicable techniques in Killer Sudoku. Check every row, column, and box systematically for 45 Rule possibilities.

Related Articles

Share this article:

Back to Blog